Credit Scores Drop at Fastest Pace Since Great Recession: What It Means for Travel Rewards
The News
Credit scores are falling faster than we've seen since the 2008 financial crisis, and it's hitting younger Americans the hardest. The national average FICO score dropped by two points this year—the steepest decline since the Great Recession—according to new data from FICO. This drop has serious implications for anyone looking to maximize travel rewards and credit card benefits.
Here are the key facts:
- Gen Z credit scores fell by 3 points, the biggest drop for any age group since 2020
- 14% of Gen Zers experienced massive credit score declines of 50+ points in the past year
- Student loan delinquencies reached a record high of 29% among borrowers with payments due
- Rising delinquency rates on auto loans, credit cards, and personal loans mirror recession-level trends
What's Driving the Credit Score Crisis
Student Debt Returns with a Vengeance
The resumption of student loan payments after the COVID-era pause is wreaking havoc on credit files. Since February, 6.1 million consumers have had student loan delinquencies added to their credit reports. That's a staggering number that represents real people struggling to keep up.
The impact hits Gen Z particularly hard because about one in three Gen Zers (34%) have open student loans—double the national average. When you're already dealing with limited credit history, a missed student loan payment can tank your score fast.
The Perfect Storm for Young Adults
It's not just student loans. Recent graduates are facing the toughest job market in years, with many taking positions that pay less than expected. Take Dimitri Tsolakis, a 22-year-old American University graduate who applied to hundreds of jobs before landing a secretary position at a law firm—a significant pay cut from his previous server job.
"My credit score took a drastic hit because I had to compromise and take a job where I'm severely underpaid," Tsolakis told CNN. With $35,000 in student debt, he's had to pause loan payments just to cover car payments and basic living expenses.
Cost of Living Pressures Mount
Even established professionals are feeling the squeeze. Sue Murphy, a Philadelphia nurse, took on a second job to cover her $70,000 in parent-PLUS loans, working 12 days on and one day off just to make the $500+ monthly payments.
The broader picture is sobering: one in five consumers say they've paid less or skipped bills entirely in the past year, up from 17% the previous year. Nearly half (47%) have cut discretionary spending, while 23% have reduced essential expenses.
Background & Context
This credit score decline reflects what economists call a "K-shaped recovery"—where those with assets tied to the stock market and rising home values are thriving, while others struggle with high interest rates and affordability challenges.
The timing couldn't be worse. Premium travel credit cards—the backbone of points and miles strategies—typically require excellent credit scores for approval. Many of the best cards like the Chase Sapphire Reserve want to see scores of 700 or higher, with premium cards often requiring 750+.
For context, during the Great Recession, average credit scores fell as unemployment spiked and Americans defaulted on mortgages and auto loans en masse. While we're not seeing mortgage defaults at similar levels today (they remain near historic lows), the pattern of declining scores across other debt categories is eerily similar.
What This Means for Travel Rewards Seekers
Winners: Those With Established Credit
If you already have strong credit and are financially stable, you're positioned to take advantage of the best credit card offers. Banks may become more generous with existing customers to retain them, potentially leading to:
- Better retention offers on premium cards
- Increased targeted upgrade bonuses
- More personalized perks and benefits
Losers: Credit Building Travelers
Anyone with damaged credit or limited credit history faces significant challenges:
- Premium card applications: Cards like the Chase Sapphire Reserve or Amex Platinum become harder to obtain
- Sign-up bonus access: Many lucrative welcome offers require excellent credit
- Lower credit limits: Approved applicants may receive smaller credit lines, limiting earning potential
Strategic Adaptations for Different Credit Situations
If Your Credit Score Has Dropped
- Focus on credit repair first before applying for new cards
- Consider secured credit cards like the Capital One Quicksilver Secured to rebuild credit history while earning rewards
- Look at credit union cards which often have more flexible approval criteria
- Become an authorized user on a family member's account with excellent payment history
If You Have Good Credit
- Apply for premium cards sooner rather than later while banks are still approving - cards like the Chase Sapphire Preferred may become harder to get
- Lock in current credit limits by keeping utilization low
- Avoid closing old cards to maintain your average account age
- Consider business credit cards which often have different approval criteria
For Gen Z and Recent Graduates
- Start with student credit cards like the Capital One Quicksilver Student designed for limited credit history
- Use your rent payments to build credit through services like Bilt Rewards
- Keep student loan payments current even if it means smaller card balances
- Build emergency fund first before chasing premium rewards
Related Financial Developments
This credit crisis doesn't exist in isolation. The Federal Reserve's interest rate decisions, inflation pressures, and changing employment patterns all factor into the equation. Recent data shows that even as headline unemployment remains low, underemployment among college graduates has surged.
The resumption of student loan payments particularly affects travel rewards strategies because many young adults who would typically be prime candidates for travel credit cards are now focused on basic financial survival rather than optimizing rewards.
Looking Ahead
Credit experts expect the trend to continue in the near term. With student loan collections ramping up and cost-of-living pressures persisting, more Americans may see their credit scores decline before they recover.
For the travel rewards community, this means banks may tighten approval criteria further. We're already seeing some issuers become more selective, and this trend could accelerate if delinquency rates continue rising.
However, history suggests this won't last forever. Credit scores eventually recovered after the 2008 crisis, and they likely will again—though it may take time.
Bottom Line
The credit score crisis is creating a two-tier system in travel rewards: those with excellent credit can access the best opportunities, while those with damaged credit face significant barriers. The key is playing the long game—focus on credit repair and financial stability first, then worry about maximizing rewards.
This isn't just about travel rewards, though. It's about financial health and opportunity. For anyone struggling with credit issues, addressing them now will pay dividends far beyond travel benefits.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What credit score do I need for premium travel credit cards? A: Most premium cards require scores of 700+, with many preferring 750+. Some cards like the Amex Platinum or Chase Sapphire Reserve typically want excellent credit (740+).
Q: Should I still apply for travel credit cards if my score has dropped? A: It depends on where you stand. If you're above 700, you may still qualify for good cards. Below 650, focus on rebuilding credit first with secured cards or becoming an authorized user.
Q: How long does it take to recover from a credit score drop? A: Recovery time varies widely. Minor drops from high utilization can recover in 1-2 months with lower balances. Missed payments and delinquencies can take 6-24 months to fully recover from.
Q: Are there travel credit cards for people with fair credit? A: Yes, cards like the Capital One VentureOne or certain airline co-branded cards accept fair credit (580-669). The rewards may be lower, but they can help rebuild credit while earning points.
Q: Should I close credit cards if I can't afford the annual fee? A: Generally no, especially during a credit crisis. Closing cards reduces your available credit and can hurt your score. Instead, try to downgrade to no-fee versions like the Chase Freedom Unlimited or negotiate retention offers.
Q: How do student loan payments affect my ability to get travel credit cards? A: Lenders look at your debt-to-income ratio and payment history. High student loan payments can reduce your approval odds or credit limits, while missed payments directly damage your credit score.
Related Resources
