Key Points

• Discover offers easier approval for beginners and no annual fees, while Amex provides premium benefits and transfer partners for experienced travelers.
• Amex has broader acceptance internationally and at premium merchants, but Discover now works at 99% of U.S. locations that accept credit cards.
• Your choice depends on your credit profile, travel frequency, and whether you value simplicity or sophisticated rewards strategies.

Choosing between credit card issuers isn't just about comparing individual cards. The issuer you go with shapes your entire rewards experience, from approval odds to customer service to how you'll ultimately use those points. Discover and American Express represent two very different approaches to credit cards, and understanding these differences can save you from applying for the wrong card or missing out on opportunities that match your lifestyle.

I've held cards from both issuers for years, and here's what you actually need to know to make the right choice for your situation.

The Quick Answer

Choose Discover if: You're building credit, want no annual fees, prefer cash back simplicity, and primarily spend in the U.S. Choose American Express if: You have good-to-excellent credit, travel frequently, want premium benefits, and value flexible points you can transfer to airlines and hotels.

Approval Standards and Credit Requirements

Discover: The Beginner-Friendly Issuer

Discover built its reputation on being accessible. They're more willing to approve applicants with limited credit history or fair credit scores (typically 640+). Their secured card option provides a genuine path to building credit without predatory terms.

What makes Discover unique is their willingness to look beyond just your credit score. They consider your overall financial picture, including income and banking relationships. I've seen readers with 6-month credit histories get approved for Discover cards when other issuers immediately declined them. If you're working on building credit quickly, Discover offers one of the most accessible entry points.

American Express: Premium Standards

Amex typically requires good-to-excellent credit (700+ for most cards, 750+ for premium cards like the Platinum). They're looking for established credit histories with demonstrated responsible usage. Their approval process considers your relationship with Amex if you're an existing cardholder, which can work in your favor for additional cards.

Amex also has stricter rules about recent credit activity. If you've opened five or more credit cards in the past six months, you'll likely face an uphill battle. They value stability over credit seeking. Understanding your FICO score helps you know when you're ready for premium Amex cards.

Rewards Philosophy and Structure

Discover's Cash Back Approach

Discover keeps rewards simple with straightforward cash back. Their rotating 5% categories change quarterly, and you'll earn 1% on everything else. The beauty here is transparency. A dollar earned is a dollar you can redeem. There's no complexity, no transfer partners, no expiration dates.

The quarterly categories typically include gas stations, restaurants, grocery stores, Amazon, PayPal, and wholesale clubs. You need to activate each quarter's categories, but it takes 30 seconds online. The $1,500 spending cap per quarter on the 5% categories means you can earn up to $300 in cash back annually from those bonuses alone. Check out our guide to the best Discover credit cards to see which specific card matches your spending patterns.

American Express's Flexible Points

Amex built their rewards program around Membership Rewards points, which offer significantly more flexibility but also more complexity. You can redeem points for cash back at 0.6 cents per point, book travel through their portal at 1 cent per point, or transfer to 21 airline and hotel partners where the value can jump to 2+ cents per point.

This flexibility is where Amex shines for frequent travelers. Transfer your points to Air Canada Aeroplan, and suddenly that business class flight to Europe that would cost $4,000 only requires 60,000 points transferred from your Amex card. That same 60,000 points would only be worth $360 as cash back, but it just bought you a $4,000 flight. Our complete American Express rewards guide breaks down exactly how to maximize this value.

Card Portfolio and Options

Discover's Streamlined Selection

Discover offers a focused lineup. The Discover it Cash Back covers general spending with rotating categories. The Discover it Miles provides a simple 1.5x miles per dollar for travel-focused consumers. The Discover it Secured helps you build credit. That's essentially it.

This simplicity means you won't spend hours comparing 15 different Discover cards. You pick the one that matches your goal and move forward. Every Discover card comes with no annual fee, which removes a major decision factor.

American Express's Extensive Range

Amex offers cards for nearly every scenario. Cash back cards like the Blue Cash Preferred. Travel cards like the Gold and Platinum. Business cards with targeted bonus categories. Co-branded airline and hotel cards with Delta, Hilton, and Marriott.

This variety lets you optimize your wallet. You might carry the Amex Gold for 4x points on dining and groceries, the Platinum for premium travel benefits, and a Blue Business Plus for 2x points on everything up to $50,000 annually. The points pool together in one Membership Rewards account, creating a powerful earning engine. See our ranking of the best American Express credit cards to understand how to build this strategy.

Acceptance and Usability

Where You Can Actually Use These Cards

Discover runs on its own payment network and now works at 99% of U.S. locations that accept credit cards. International acceptance improved significantly through partnerships with Diners Club and other networks, but you'll still encounter places abroad that don't take Discover.

American Express acceptance in the U.S. approaches Discover's level for everyday merchants, but Amex particularly excels at premium establishments, hotels, airlines, and upscale restaurants. International acceptance is stronger than Discover's, especially in major travel destinations.

The practical reality: You'll rarely face issues using either card for daily U.S. purchases. International travel is where Amex pulls ahead. I always carry a Visa or Mastercard backup regardless of which issuer I'm primarily using.

Customer Service and Cardholder Experience

Discover's Service Reputation

Discover consistently ranks at the top for customer service in J.D. Power studies. Their U.S.-based call centers mean you'll speak with representatives who have full account access and decision-making authority. Average hold times run under two minutes.

The website and mobile app are straightforward without unnecessary complexity. You won't find cutting-edge features, but everything works reliably. Fraud protection is solid, with real-time alerts and a freeze feature you can toggle instantly from the app.

American Express's Premium Touch

Amex service varies by card tier. Basic cards get good service; premium cards like the Platinum get exceptional service. The Centurion Concierge can handle restaurant reservations, event tickets, travel planning, and unusual requests that regular customer service won't touch.

Their mobile app leads the industry with features like Amex Offers (targeted cash back at specific merchants), spending analysis, and seamless point transfers. You'll also get purchase protection, extended warranties, and return protection that exceed what Discover offers.

Annual Fees and Value Proposition

Discover: Zero Annual Fees

Every consumer Discover card charges $0 annually. This removes the pressure to "break even" on your card. Whether you spend $500 or $50,000, you're not fighting against an annual fee eating into your rewards.

For casual card users or those building credit, this approach makes perfect sense. You'll earn rewards without worrying about minimum spending thresholds to justify keeping the card.

American Express: Premium Benefits Justify Fees

Amex charges annual fees ranging from $0 (Blue Cash Everyday) to $695 (Platinum Card). The value calculation becomes crucial. The Platinum's $695 fee includes $200 in airline credits, $200 in Uber credits, $189 in CLEAR credits, and other benefits that can exceed the fee if you use them.

This creates a different mindset. You're not just getting a payment card; you're buying into a benefits ecosystem. If you travel frequently and use the lounge access, hotel status, and credits, the math works beautifully. If you don't, you're paying for perks you're not using.

Sign-Up Bonuses and Promotional Offers

Discover's Unique First-Year Match

Discover doubles all cash back you earn in your first year. This effectively turns the 5% rotating categories into 10% and the 1% base rate into 2%. On maximum spending, that's an extra $300+ in your first year beyond the regular rewards.

This approach rewards actual usage rather than requiring a large upfront spend. You'll benefit whether you spend $3,000 or $30,000 in that first year.

American Express's Substantial Welcome Offers

Amex bonuses can be substantial. The Platinum Card regularly offers 80,000-125,000 points (worth $800-$2,500+ depending on redemption) after spending $6,000-$8,000 in the first few months. The Gold Card typically offers 60,000-90,000 points after $4,000 in spending.

These bonuses alone can justify the annual fee for the first year, especially if you transfer points to travel partners. However, you need to hit the spending threshold within the time limit, which requires planning. Check our current list of the best credit card bonuses to see current Amex offers.

Building Your Card Strategy

When Discover Makes More Sense

Start with Discover if you're building credit history, want to keep things simple, or primarily spend in the U.S. The no-annual-fee structure means you can keep the card indefinitely without worrying about justifying the cost. The cash back model requires zero learning curve.

Discover also works well as a supplementary card even if you primarily use other issuers. Activate those quarterly 5% categories and pull out your Discover card when they align with your spending. Our guide to best cash back credit cards shows you how to combine Discover with other cash back cards for maximum returns.

When American Express Delivers More Value

Choose Amex when you have established credit, travel regularly, and want sophisticated rewards strategies. The transfer partners create opportunities for outsized value that cash back simply can't match. Premium benefits like lounge access, hotel status, and purchase protections add tangible value beyond points earning.

Amex also makes sense if you plan to build a multi-card strategy. The ability to pool points from multiple cards into one Membership Rewards account creates powerful earning potential. If you're deciding between travel credit cards, Amex's ecosystem offers unmatched flexibility for frequent travelers.

The Multi-Issuer Approach

Here's what experienced points collectors understand: You don't have to choose just one issuer. Many successful strategies involve cards from multiple issuers, each playing a specific role.

A common setup might include a Discover it Cash Back for rotating 5% categories, an Amex Gold for 4x points on dining and groceries, and a no-annual-fee Visa or Mastercard for places that don't accept Amex or Discover. This combination captures elevated earning across most spending while maintaining universal acceptance.

The key is starting with one issuer that matches your current situation, then strategically adding cards from other issuers as your credit profile improves and you better understand your spending patterns.

Making Your Decision

Your choice between Discover and American Express ultimately comes down to where you are in your credit journey and what you value in a card relationship.

If you're starting out, want simplicity, or prefer cash back you can use anywhere, Discover provides an excellent foundation. The no-annual-fee structure and accessible approval standards remove barriers to entry.

If you have established credit, travel regularly, and want to maximize value through strategic redemptions, American Express offers tools and benefits that justify the additional complexity and potential annual fees.

Both issuers have earned their reputations through decades of consistent service. You won't go wrong with either choice. The real mistake is applying for cards that don't match your spending patterns, credit profile, or financial goals.

Start with the issuer that fits your current situation. You can always expand to other issuers as your strategy evolves and your credit profile strengthens. The credit card landscape rewards those who match their cards to their actual spending and travel patterns, not those who chase every sign-up bonus regardless of fit.

This article contains affiliate links. If you apply through our links, we may earn a commission at no cost to you, which helps us continue sharing points and miles strategies with the community.