Key Points

• The Blue Cash Preferred earns 6% back on groceries (up to $6,000 annually) and makes sense when you value simplicity over transfer partners.
• Best for households spending $400+ monthly on groceries who want guaranteed value without worrying about award availability.
• At $95 annually, the fee pays for itself with just $132 in monthly grocery spending, making it easier to justify than most travel cards.

Introduction

I'll be honest: as someone who usually evangelizes about transferable points, recommending a cash back card feels a bit like breaking character. But here's the thing—the Blue Cash Preferred from American Express has quietly become one of the smartest cards in my wallet, and it has nothing to do with award flights or hotel transfers.

If you're spending serious money on groceries every month and you're tired of calculating redemption values, this card delivers straightforward 6% cash back with zero complexity. No transfer partners, no sweet spots to memorize, no award availability to stress about. Just simple, reliable cash back that hits your account like clockwork. Let me show you exactly when this card makes more sense than chasing points.

Quick Summary

Best For: Households spending $400+ monthly on groceries who want guaranteed value
Standout Benefit: Industry-leading 6% back on U.S. supermarkets (up to $6,000 annually)
Biggest Drawback: Value drops after hitting the $6,000 grocery cap
Current Offer: $250 statement credit after spending $3,000 in the first 6 months

Blue Cash Preferred Overview

The Blue Cash Preferred is American Express's flagship cash back card, and it's built around one simple premise: give you the highest grocery rewards rate on the market and get out of your way. While cards like the Amex Gold earn 4x Membership Rewards points at U.S. supermarkets (up to $25,000 annually), the Blue Cash Preferred takes a different approach with straightforward 6% cash back.

The card costs $95 annually, but that's waived for the first year. You'll earn 6% back at U.S. supermarkets on up to $6,000 in purchases annually, then 1% after that. You also get 6% on select U.S. streaming subscriptions, 3% at U.S. gas stations and on transit, and 1% on everything else.

American Express currently offers a $250 statement credit when you spend $3,000 in the first six months. That's a solid welcome offer for a cash back card, especially considering you can hit that threshold in about three months of normal grocery shopping for most families.

Key Features and Benefits

6% Cash Back at U.S. Supermarkets

This is the card's headline feature, and for good reason. At 6% back, you're earning more on groceries than virtually any other card on the market. For context, most flat-rate cash back cards max out at 2%, and even category cards typically cap at 3-5%.

The math is simple: spend $500 monthly on groceries, and you'll earn $360 annually in cash back (that's $30 per month for six months at 6%, then $5 per month at 1% after you hit the cap). After the $95 annual fee, you're still netting $265. Compare that to a 2% flat-rate card earning just $120 annually on the same spending.

Here's the real kicker: unlike points that can vary in value depending on how you redeem them, 6% cash back is 6% cash back. No availability calendars, no transfer bonuses to wait for, no devaluations. It's guaranteed value that shows up in your account within a few billing cycles.

6% Back on Select Streaming Services

The card also earns 6% back on select U.S. streaming subscriptions, which quietly adds up. If you're paying for Netflix, Hulu, Disney+, or similar services, you're earning an extra dollar for every $16.67 you spend. Not life-changing, but it's nice to offset a few months of your subscriptions each year.

For most households juggling multiple streaming services, this benefit alone can contribute $30-50 annually in rewards. Combined with the grocery category, you're building a solid foundation of cash back without overthinking your spending.

3% Back on Gas and Transit

The 3% category for gas stations and transit isn't groundbreaking, but it's useful for daily drivers and commuters. If you're spending $200 monthly on gas, that's an extra $72 annually. Transit includes taxis, rideshare, parking, tolls, trains, and buses—basically anything that gets you from point A to point B.

This category positions the Blue Cash Preferred as more than just a grocery card. It becomes a practical everyday card for the expenses that actually impact your monthly budget, not just aspirational travel spending.

Disney Streaming Credit

The Blue Cash Preferred includes up to a $10 monthly statement credit when you use your enrolled card to pay for Disney+, Hulu, or ESPN+ subscriptions. That's $120 annually, which more than covers the $95 annual fee before you even factor in the 6% grocery rewards.

If you're already subscribed to any Disney streaming service, this benefit alone makes the annual fee a non-issue. Even if you're not currently subscribed, the math makes adding a Disney+ subscription worth considering just to maximize the card's value.

Earning Structure

The Blue Cash Preferred's earning structure is refreshingly simple:

• 6% cash back: U.S. supermarkets (up to $6,000 annually, then 1%)
• 6% cash back: Select U.S. streaming subscriptions
• 3% cash back: U.S. gas stations and transit
• 1% cash back: Everything else

Once you hit that $6,000 grocery cap, you're earning just 1% back at supermarkets. This happens around mid-year if you're spending $500 monthly on groceries. At that point, you'll want to shift your grocery spending to another card for the second half of the year—either a flat-rate 2% card or a different category card.

The key is understanding that this card is optimized for the first $6,000 in grocery spending. Beyond that, the value proposition shifts, and you're better off using other cards in your wallet.

Pros and Cons

Pros

• Industry-leading 6% cash back on groceries (up to $6,000 annually) delivers guaranteed value without worrying about redemption rates or availability.
• The Disney streaming credit worth up to $120 annually effectively eliminates the annual fee for most subscribers.
• Cash back posts quickly to your account and can be redeemed as a statement credit with no minimum threshold or complexity.
• First-year annual fee waiver gives you 12 months to test whether the card's earning structure matches your actual spending patterns.
• Strong welcome offer of $250 after $3,000 in spending provides immediate value and typically covers 4-6 months of groceries.

Cons

• Earning drops to just 1% after hitting the $6,000 grocery cap, which happens around mid-year for households spending $500+ monthly.
• The $95 annual fee requires at least $132 in monthly grocery spending to break even compared to no-fee alternatives.
• Foreign transaction fees of 2.7% make this card impractical for international use when better no foreign transaction fee options exist.

How Blue Cash Preferred Compares

Blue Cash Preferred vs. Amex Gold

The Amex Gold earns 4x Membership Rewards points at U.S. supermarkets on up to $25,000 annually. That's a lower earn rate (4x vs. 6%), but with a much higher cap and the flexibility of transferable points.

If you're booking premium cabin flights through transfer partners and getting 2+ cents per point in value, the Amex Gold pulls ahead. At 4x points worth 2 cents each, you're effectively earning 8% back on groceries—better than the Blue Cash Preferred's 6%.

But here's the catch: that math only works if you're actually transferring points to partners and finding good availability. If you're primarily using points for portal bookings at 1 cent per point, or if you're not traveling enough to use the points, the Blue Cash Preferred's guaranteed 6% cash back is the smarter play.

The Blue Cash Preferred also costs $95 annually versus $250 for the Amex Gold. Even with the Gold's dining credits, you're paying $155 more per year. For many households focused on grocery spending specifically, the Blue Cash Preferred delivers better value.

Blue Cash Preferred vs. Blue Cash Everyday

American Express also offers the Blue Cash Everyday, which has no annual fee and earns 3% back at U.S. supermarkets (on up to $6,000 annually).

The math here is straightforward. At $500 monthly grocery spending:

• Blue Cash Preferred nets $265 annually after the $95 fee
• Blue Cash Everyday nets $180 annually with no fee

You need to spend about $264 monthly on groceries for the Blue Cash Preferred to pull ahead. Below that threshold, stick with the Blue Cash Everyday. Above that threshold, the Blue Cash Preferred's higher earn rate justifies the annual fee.

Blue Cash Preferred vs. Chase Freedom Flex

The Chase Freedom Flex has no annual fee and earns 5% back on rotating quarterly categories, which sometimes includes grocery stores. But "sometimes" is the key word—you're not guaranteed grocery rewards every quarter, and you're capped at $1,500 in spending per category per quarter.

The Blue Cash Preferred gives you guaranteed 6% back on groceries year-round with a higher annual cap. If consistent grocery rewards are your priority, the Blue Cash Preferred wins despite the annual fee.

Who Should Get Blue Cash Preferred

Great Fit For:

Families spending $400+ monthly on groceries. You'll easily justify the annual fee and maximize the earning potential before hitting the $6,000 cap. The Disney streaming credit and gas rewards are just bonuses on top of the core grocery value.

Points enthusiasts who want guaranteed value for daily spending. If you're holding travel cards for flights and hotels but want simple cash back for groceries and gas, the Blue Cash Preferred fills that gap perfectly. Not everything needs to earn transferable points.

Anyone already paying for Disney+, Hulu, or ESPN+. The $120 annual streaming credit covers the $95 fee and then some. At that point, the 6% grocery rewards are pure profit.

People who value simplicity over optimization. If tracking transfer partners and award availability sounds exhausting, the Blue Cash Preferred delivers strong returns without the mental overhead. Cash back is cash back—no calculations required.

Not Ideal For:

Light grocery shoppers spending under $300 monthly. You won't earn enough to justify the $95 annual fee compared to no annual fee alternatives. Consider the Blue Cash Everyday instead.

International travelers making frequent purchases abroad. The 2.7% foreign transaction fee kills the value when you're traveling. You're better off with cards that waive these fees entirely.

Grocery shoppers who can consistently get 2+ cents per point in value from transferable points programs. The math favors the Amex Gold at that redemption level, especially with its higher $25,000 cap. But be honest with yourself about whether you'll actually achieve those redemption rates consistently.

Maximizing the Blue Cash Preferred

Hit the Disney Streaming Credit Every Month

If you're not already subscribed to Disney+, Hulu, or ESPN+, consider adding one just to maximize this benefit. At $10 monthly, you're getting $120 back annually, which more than covers the $95 annual fee before groceries even enter the equation.

Switch Cards After Hitting the $6,000 Cap

Once you hit the grocery cap around mid-year, pivot to a different card for the rest of the year. A flat-rate 2% card beats the Blue Cash Preferred's 1% earning rate after the cap. Plan ahead and you'll maximize rewards across your entire annual grocery spending.

Use for Gas and Transit During High-Spending Months

The 3% back on gas and transit adds up faster than you think. If you're taking a road trip or commuting more during certain months, the Blue Cash Preferred becomes your go-to card for these categories automatically.

Pair with Travel Cards for a Complete Strategy

The Blue Cash Preferred works brilliantly alongside travel cards like the Chase Sapphire Preferred or Capital One Venture X. Use travel cards for flights, hotels, and dining where transferable points shine. Use the Blue Cash Preferred for groceries, streaming, and gas where cash back makes more sense. You don't have to choose one strategy—build a wallet that optimizes each category.

FAQ Section

Is the Blue Cash Preferred worth it with the $95 annual fee?

If you're spending at least $400 monthly on groceries, absolutely. You'll earn about $288 in grocery rewards annually, netting $193 after the fee. Add in the Disney streaming credit, and you're easily ahead. Below $300 monthly in grocery spending, consider the no-fee Blue Cash Everyday instead.

What counts as a U.S. supermarket for the 6% rewards?

Major grocery chains like Kroger, Safeway, Publix, and Whole Foods qualify. Warehouse clubs like Costco and Sam's Club do NOT qualify, nor do Target and Walmart. Smaller independent grocery stores usually work, but check your statements to confirm. When in doubt, American Express's merchant category codes determine eligibility, not the store's name.

What happens after I spend $6,000 on groceries?

Your earning rate drops to 1% back on groceries for the rest of the year. At that point, switch to a 2% flat-rate card for grocery spending. The cap resets January 1st, so you'll start earning 6% again in the new year.

Can I have both the Blue Cash Preferred and the Amex Gold?

Yes, you can hold both cards simultaneously. Many people do exactly this—using the Amex Gold for dining and certain travel purchases while using the Blue Cash Preferred specifically for groceries where the 6% cash back beats the 4x points, especially if you're not consistently getting 1.5+ cents per point in value.

Does the Disney streaming credit require enrollment?

Yes, you need to enroll your card for the Disney streaming benefit. Once enrolled, charges for Disney+, Hulu, or ESPN+ automatically receive a statement credit up to $10 monthly. The process takes about two minutes through your Amex account.

Final Verdict

Look, I spend most of my time on this site talking about transfer partners, sweet spots, and squeezing maximum value from travel rewards programs. But the Blue Cash Preferred is a reminder that sometimes the best strategy is the simplest one.

At 6% back on groceries—an expense you can't avoid and probably can't manufacture—this card delivers guaranteed value month after month. Add in the Disney streaming credit that covers the annual fee, plus 3% on gas and transit, and you've got a practical everyday card that requires zero mental gymnastics.

Is it going to book your next business class flight to Tokyo? No. But it'll put $300+ back in your pocket every year from spending you're already doing, and sometimes that's exactly what makes sense.

The Blue Cash Preferred works best as a complement to your travel card strategy, not a replacement for it. Use it where cash back beats points, and use transferable points cards where the flexibility matters. That's how you build a wallet that actually maximizes returns across all your spending.

This article contains affiliate links. If you apply through our links, we may earn a commission at no cost to you, which helps us continue sharing points and miles strategies with the community.