Key Points

• Americans left $27.9 billion in credit card rewards unclaimed in 2024, primarily from unused cash-back programs.
• The average household loses $583 annually by not redeeming earned rewards before expiration or account changes.
• Simple tracking systems and strategic card choices can ensure you never lose a single point or dollar you've earned.

Introduction

Here's a number that should make you uncomfortable: $27.9 billion. That's how much money Americans left on the table in credit card rewards during 2024, according to a recent WalletHub study. To put that in perspective, the average household threw away $583 in rewards they'd already earned.

This isn't about missing out on potential rewards or not having the right cards. These are points and cash back that people earned but never claimed. The money was sitting there, waiting to be used, and millions of cardholders just… forgot about it. Or didn't know how to use it. Or thought they'd get around to it eventually.

If you're reading this, you're probably not going to make that same mistake. Let me show you exactly why this happens and how to make sure every single reward you earn actually ends up in your pocket or funding your next trip.

The Real Numbers Behind Unclaimed Rewards

The WalletHub study revealed some eye-opening trends. While the $27.9 billion figure represents all unclaimed rewards, cash-back programs took the biggest hit. Why? Because people assume cash back is simple, set it and forget it. But here's what actually happens:

Cash-back rewards often require manual redemption. Unlike points that might automatically apply to your balance, many cash-back programs need you to log in and actually claim your money. Miss that step, close your account, or let your card sit inactive, and that money disappears.

The average cash-back cardholder left $215 unclaimed in 2024. For travel rewards enthusiasts, the number was even higher at $368 per household. These aren't small amounts. We're talking about real money that could fund a weekend trip, cover holiday shopping, or pay down debt.

Why Smart People Lose Rewards They've Already Earned

Expiration Policies You Didn't Know About

Most people know that airline miles can expire. What they don't realize is that many credit card rewards programs also have expiration rules that can catch you off guard.

Take Citi ThankYou Points. If you don't have a card that earns ThankYou Points, your points expire after just 36 months of inactivity. Close your Citi Premier card thinking you'll use those points later? You've got less than three years before they're gone. Understanding Citi ThankYou Points expiration policies can save you thousands in lost value.

The Capital One Venture X Rewards Credit Card handles this better. Your miles don't expire as long as your account stays open, giving you more flexibility in planning redemptions.

Account Closure Wipes Out Your Balance

This is the big one. Close your credit card account before redeeming your rewards, and they're gone. No grace period, no transfer option, nothing. The banks aren't going to remind you either.

I've seen people close cards after paying off balances, forgetting about the 50,000 points sitting in their account. That's potentially $500 to $1,000 in travel value, vanished in an instant.

You're Waiting for the "Perfect" Redemption

Here's a truth bomb: there's no such thing as a perfect redemption. While you're holding out for that elusive 2 cents per point value, your points are losing value through program devaluations, or worse, you're missing expiration deadlines.

The best redemption is the one you actually use. A business class flight to Europe at 1.7 cents per point that you book and enjoy is infinitely better than 100,000 points that expire while you're waiting for a theoretical 2.5 cent redemption you never find.

You Have Too Many Cards and Lost Track

Multiple credit cards can maximize your earning potential, but they also increase the complexity of managing rewards. When you're juggling points across five different programs, it's easy to forget about that older card with 15,000 points sitting idle.

The Cash-Back Trap That Catches Everyone

Cash-back cards seem foolproof. Earn a percentage back on purchases, get money. Simple, right? Not quite.

Many cash-back programs require you to actively claim your rewards. The Citi Double Cash Card automatically applies rewards as a statement credit once you reach certain thresholds, which helps prevent losses. But other programs make you log in and manually request redemption.

Then there's the minimum redemption threshold. Some cards won't let you cash out until you hit $25 or even $50 in rewards. If you close your account before reaching that threshold, you lose everything you've earned.

The Chase Freedom Unlimited offers more flexibility. Your cash back earns as Ultimate Rewards points, which means you can transfer them to a premium Chase card like the Chase Sapphire Preferred for better value, or simply redeem for cash with no minimum if you prefer.

How to Never Lose Another Reward

Set Up a Rewards Tracking System

Stop relying on memory. Create a simple spreadsheet or use a tool like AwardWallet to track every rewards balance across all your cards. Include these details for each card:

• Current points or cash-back balance
• Last activity date
• Expiration policy and date
• Minimum redemption threshold
• Annual fee renewal date

Set calendar reminders for 30 and 60 days before any expiration dates or annual fee hits. This gives you time to either use the rewards or decide if the card is worth keeping.

Understand Each Program's Rules

Not all rewards programs work the same way. Take 15 minutes to read the terms for each card you hold. Specifically, find out:

Do points expire? If so, under what conditions? Many programs like Chase Ultimate Rewards keep points alive as long as your account is open. Others require activity every 18-24 months.

What happens when you close your account? Some programs give you 30 days to use rewards. Others wipe them immediately. Know before you close.

Are there minimum redemption amounts? If your card requires $25 minimum redemptions and you only have $20 earned, make sure you reach that threshold before closing the account.

Choose Cards with Better Protections

If you're worried about losing rewards, select cards with policies that protect your points:

The American Express Gold Card offers Membership Rewards points that never expire as long as you have any Amex card that earns Membership Rewards. You could close your Gold Card and your points stay safe with a no-fee card like the Amex EveryDay.

The Chase Sapphire Reserve gives you Ultimate Rewards points with no expiration date. Close the Reserve but keep a no-fee Chase Freedom Unlimited, and your points remain accessible.

Develop a Redemption Strategy

Don't just earn rewards aimlessly. Have a plan for using them. This doesn't mean you need to book travel immediately, but you should know generally what you're saving for and approximately when you'll need the points.

If you're earning Marriott Bonvoy points, are you saving for a specific luxury property? If so, check award availability and pricing regularly. Programs change, and that hotel that costs 50,000 points today might jump to 70,000 points after a devaluation.

Use Automatic Redemptions Wisely

Some cards offer automatic cash-back redemptions. The Chase Freedom Flex can automatically apply rewards as a statement credit when you reach $25. This prevents you from forgetting to redeem, but it also means you can't transfer those rewards to a premium card for potentially better value.

Consider your redemption goals before enabling auto-redemption. If you want maximum flexibility, transferring points between Chase cards might offer better long-term value than automatic cash back.

The Strategic Approach to Multiple Cards

Having multiple credit cards is smart for maximizing rewards, but only if you can manage them effectively. Here's how to handle multiple cards without losing track:

Limit yourself to 3-4 active cards. You don't need 10 different cards to maximize rewards. A well-chosen portfolio of 3-4 cards can cover all your major spending categories while remaining manageable. Our guide to the best overall credit cards can help you build a strategic wallet.

Consolidate where possible. Programs like Chase Ultimate Rewards and American Express Membership Rewards let you hold multiple cards but pool all points in one place. This makes tracking much easier than managing separate balances for every card.

What to Do Before Closing Any Credit Card

Planning to close a credit card? Follow this checklist to ensure you don't lose any rewards:

Check your rewards balance. Log in and verify exactly how many points or how much cash back you have available. Don't trust your memory or assume you know.

Understand the redemption timeline. Does the bank give you 30 days after closure to redeem? Or do rewards disappear immediately? Call customer service if the terms aren't clear.

Redeem or transfer everything. Use your rewards or transfer them to another card in the same program before you close. For Chase cards, this means moving points to another Ultimate Rewards card. For Amex, transfer to any other Membership Rewards card.

Confirm the transfer or redemption processed. Don't just submit the request and close the card. Wait until you see the points or cash back in your account before proceeding with closure.

The Annual Fee Decision

Annual fees complicate the rewards equation. That $95 or $550 fee can feel like a waste if you're not actively using the card. But closing the card to avoid the fee means potentially losing thousands in rewards.

Here's the smart approach: About 60 days before your annual fee posts, assess your situation. Do you have rewards to redeem? If yes, use them or transfer them to another card first. Our analysis of when annual fees make sense can help with this decision.

Can you downgrade instead of close? Many premium cards offer no-fee alternatives. You can downgrade a Chase Sapphire Reserve to a Chase Freedom Unlimited and keep your Ultimate Rewards points safe while avoiding the annual fee.

Common Mistakes That Cost You Money

Assuming Points Transfer Between Programs

You can't transfer Marriott Bonvoy points to Chase Ultimate Rewards, or American Express points to Citi ThankYou. Programs are separate ecosystems. Once you transfer points to an airline or hotel program, they're locked in that program's rules and expiration policies.

Forgetting About Sign-Up Bonuses

That 60,000-point welcome bonus you earned? It expires under the same rules as points you earn from spending. Don't assume bonus points get special treatment. They don't.

Not Reading Program Updates

Loyalty programs change their rules constantly. A program that previously kept points alive with any activity might implement new expiration policies. Airlines and hotels send emails about these changes, but most people delete them without reading.

The Bottom Line on Protecting Your Rewards

That $27.9 billion in unclaimed rewards represents real money that hardworking people earned and then lost through inaction or confusion. You've already done the hard part by earning these rewards through your everyday spending. Don't let them disappear because you weren't paying attention.

The solution isn't complicated. Track your balances, understand each program's rules, and have a general plan for using your rewards. You don't need to be obsessive about it. A quarterly 15-minute review of your rewards accounts will catch most problems before they become losses.

Remember, reward points and cash back aren't Monopoly money. They represent real value that you've earned. Treat them with the same care you'd give cash sitting in your wallet. Check your balances regularly, use what you've earned, and never close a card before claiming every dollar you're owed.

The best reward program is the one where you actually use the rewards. Don't be part of next year's $27.9 billion statistic.

This article contains affiliate links. If you apply through our links, we may earn a commission at no cost to you, which helps us continue sharing points and miles strategies with the community.