Key Points

• Store credit cards are often easier to get approved for than regular credit cards, making them a viable option for building credit from scratch.
• They report to credit bureaus just like regular cards, but their limited usability and high interest rates require careful management.
• Regular credit cards with no annual fee offer more flexibility and better long-term value for most credit builders.

Introduction

You're standing at the checkout, and the cashier offers you 20% off today's purchase if you open a store credit card. It sounds tempting, especially if you're trying to build credit and have been denied for regular credit cards. But will a store card actually help you build credit, or is it a trap that'll cost you more in the long run?

Here's the truth: store credit cards can work for building credit, but they're not the best option for everyone. Let me walk you through exactly how they work, when they make sense, and what alternatives might serve you better.

Quick Answer

Store credit cards do build credit when used responsibly. They report to the major credit bureaus just like regular credit cards, so making on-time payments and keeping balances low will help establish your credit history. However, their limited usability, higher interest rates, and lower credit limits make them less ideal than flexible starter cards like secured credit cards or student cards for most people building credit.

What Are Store Credit Cards?

Store credit cards are credit cards issued by specific retailers that can typically only be used at that retailer's stores or website. Think Target Circle Card, Amazon Store Card, or Macy's credit card. Some store cards are "closed-loop" (only usable at that specific retailer), while others are "open-loop" co-branded cards (usable anywhere that accepts Visa or Mastercard).

The Two Types of Store Cards

Closed-Loop Store CardsThese work only at a specific retailer. For example, a Nordstrom store card can only be used at Nordstrom and Nordstrom Rack. You can't use it at the gas station or grocery store.

Open-Loop Co-Branded CardsThese are branded with a retailer's name but carry a Visa, Mastercard, or Amex logo, making them usable anywhere those networks are accepted. The Target Circle Card is a closed-loop store card, while many airline and hotel cards are open-loop co-branded cards.

For credit building purposes, we're primarily talking about closed-loop store cards since those are the ones marketed as "easier to get approved for."

How Store Credit Cards Build Credit

Store credit cards build credit through the same mechanisms as regular credit cards. Here's exactly how it works.

They Report to Credit Bureaus

Most major store credit cards report your account activity to all three credit bureaus: Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion. This means your payment history, credit utilization, and account age all contribute to your credit score just like a regular credit card would.

When you make on-time payments, those positive payment records appear on your credit report. Since payment history makes up 35% of your FICO score, this is the most powerful way store cards help build credit.

They Establish Credit History

One of the challenges when building credit from scratch is establishing any credit history at all. Store cards help solve this problem by giving you that first tradeline on your credit report. The longer you keep the account open and in good standing, the more you benefit from the account aging and contributing to your average age of accounts.

They Impact Your Credit Utilization

Credit utilization—the percentage of available credit you're using—accounts for 30% of your FICO score. Store cards add to your total available credit, which can help lower your overall utilization ratio. However, this benefit is limited by the typically low credit limits on store cards.

The Real Advantages of Store Cards for Credit Building

Let me be honest about where store cards actually shine.

Easier Approval Standards

This is the biggest advantage. Store cards generally have more lenient approval requirements than traditional credit cards. If you have limited credit history, a lower credit score (often 600-640 range), or previous credit issues, you're more likely to get approved for a store card than a regular rewards card.

Why? Retailers want your business. The credit card is a tool to encourage loyalty and spending at their stores. They're willing to take on slightly more risk because they profit from your purchases.

No Annual Fee

Most store credit cards don't charge an annual fee, which means you can keep the account open indefinitely without cost. This helps your credit score by aging your credit history and maintaining your available credit.

Immediate Discount Incentive

Many stores offer a significant discount (15-25%) on your first purchase when you open a card. If you're making a large purchase anyway, this can offset some of the card's disadvantages. However, don't let a one-time discount convince you to open a card you don't need.

The Significant Disadvantages You Need to Know

Here's where I need to be straight with you about the downsides.

Extremely High Interest Rates

Store credit cards typically charge interest rates between 25% and 30% APR, significantly higher than the average credit card APR of around 20-24%. If you carry a balance, the interest charges can quickly wipe out any benefits from rewards or discounts.

Let's look at real numbers. Say you charge $500 on a store card with 28% APR and make only minimum payments of $25/month. You'll pay about $280 in interest over 2 years. That's more than half of what you originally borrowed.

Limited Usability

Closed-loop store cards can only be used at one retailer. This limitation creates several problems for credit building:

First, you might not shop at that store regularly, making it harder to use the card and keep the account active. Second, you can't use the card for essential purchases like gas or groceries, which limits your ability to build payment history naturally. Third, if the retailer goes out of business or you move away from their locations, the card becomes useless but you should keep it open for credit history purposes.

Lower Credit Limits

Store cards typically start with credit limits between $300 and $1,500, much lower than regular credit cards. While any available credit helps your utilization ratio, these small limits mean one moderate purchase can max out your card and spike your utilization, potentially hurting your score temporarily.

Temptation to Overspend

This is the psychological trap. Having a store card might encourage you to spend more at that retailer than you normally would. The card makes it easy to justify purchases because you're "building credit," but if you're carrying balances and paying interest, you're losing money while supposedly building credit.

When Store Cards Actually Make Sense

Despite the disadvantages, there are specific situations where opening a store card for credit building makes strategic sense.

You Have No Other Credit Options

If you've been denied for secured credit cards, student cards, and other starter options, a store card might be your only path to establishing credit. In this case, it's worth the limitations to get that first tradeline on your credit report.

You Already Shop There Regularly

If you're going to spend money at Target, Home Depot, or Amazon anyway, using a store card for those purchases and paying the balance in full each month makes sense. You're not changing your spending habits, just the payment method.

You Can Pay in Full Every Month

This is non-negotiable. Store cards only make sense if you commit to paying your balance in full every single month. The moment you start carrying balances and paying 28% interest, you're losing money and defeating the purpose of building credit.

You Have a Specific Strategy

Some credit builders use store cards as part of a broader strategy. For example, you might open a store card, make one small purchase per month, set up autopay for the full balance, and let the account age while you focus on building credit through other means.

Better Alternatives for Building Credit

Let me show you options that typically work better than store cards.

Secured Credit Cards

A secured credit card requires a refundable security deposit (typically $200-$500) that becomes your credit limit. These cards report to credit bureaus just like unsecured cards, but they're much easier to get approved for since the deposit protects the issuer from risk.

The advantages over store cards are significant: you can use them anywhere, they often have lower interest rates, and many issuers upgrade you to an unsecured card after 6-12 months of responsible use and return your deposit.

Consider cards like the Discover it Secured, which even offers cash back rewards, or the Capital One Platinum Secured Card. Both report to all three credit bureaus and have paths to upgrade to regular unsecured cards.

Student Credit Cards

If you're currently enrolled in college, student credit cards offer another excellent option. These cards are designed for people with limited credit history and offer more flexibility than store cards while still being relatively easy to get approved for.

Cards like the Discover it Student Cash Back or the Capital One SavorOne Student Card offer real rewards, no annual fees, and the ability to use them for all your purchases, not just at one retailer.

Becoming an Authorized User

This strategy doesn't require a credit check at all. If you have a family member or trusted friend with good credit, they can add you as an authorized user on their credit card account. You'll benefit from their positive payment history and the card's age, which can help you build credit quickly.

The key is to make sure the card issuer reports authorized user accounts to the credit bureaus (most major issuers do) and that the primary cardholder has excellent payment history and low utilization.

Credit Builder Loans

Credit builder loans are specifically designed to help people build credit. You make monthly payments into a savings account, and once you've paid the full amount, you receive the money. The lender reports your payments to credit bureaus, helping you establish positive payment history while saving money.

These aren't credit cards, but they're worth mentioning because they achieve the credit-building goal without the temptation to overspend or the risk of high-interest debt.

How to Use a Store Card Effectively for Credit Building

If you decide a store card is your best option right now, here's exactly how to use it strategically.

Start With Small, Planned Purchases

Don't charge large amounts immediately. Instead, use your store card for small, planned purchases you would make anyway. Buy a $20 item each month, pay it off in full, and let the positive payment history accumulate.

This approach keeps your utilization low, demonstrates responsible use, and minimizes the risk of overspending or carrying balances.

Set Up Automatic Payments

The single biggest factor in your credit score is payment history. Never miss a payment. Set up automatic payments for at least the minimum due, but ideally for the full statement balance.

Most store cards allow you to link a checking account and schedule automatic payments. Do this immediately after opening the card. Even if you think you'll remember to pay manually, automation ensures you never accidentally miss a payment.

Keep Utilization Below 30%

Try to keep your balance below 30% of your credit limit at all times. If your store card has a $500 limit, that means keeping your balance under $150. Better yet, aim for under 10% utilization ($50 on a $500 limit) for maximum credit score benefit.

If you need to make a larger purchase, consider paying down the balance before the statement closes to keep your reported utilization low.

Monitor Your Credit Progress

Check your credit score regularly (free through services like Credit Karma or your card issuer) to see how your responsible use is paying off. You should see your score start to improve within 3-6 months of consistent on-time payments.

Have an Exit Strategy

Don't plan to keep a store card forever as your only credit card. Use it as a stepping stone to better credit products. After 6-12 months of positive payment history with your store card, you should qualify for better options like cash back credit cards or travel rewards cards.

Once you have other cards, you can keep the store card open with minimal activity (one small purchase every few months) to maintain its contribution to your credit age, or close it if the annual cost or temptation to overspend outweighs the benefits.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Applying for Multiple Store Cards at Once

Don't go on a store card application spree. Each application results in a hard inquiry on your credit report, which can temporarily lower your score. More importantly, opening several new accounts at once dramatically lowers your average age of accounts, which hurts your score.

Open one card, use it responsibly for several months, and only then consider adding another account if needed.

Carrying Balances to "Build Credit Faster"

This is a dangerous myth. You do not need to carry a balance and pay interest to build credit. Your payment history is reported whether you pay interest or not. Always pay your full statement balance to avoid interest charges while still building excellent credit.

Opening a Card Just for the Discount

That 20% off your first purchase sounds great, but it's not worth opening a credit card you don't need. The hard inquiry, new account, and potential temptation to overspend often outweigh a one-time discount. Only open a store card if it fits into your broader credit-building strategy.

Ignoring the Card After Opening It

Some issuers may close inactive accounts after several months of no use. If a store card is your only credit account, this could hurt your credit score by reducing your available credit and eliminating your only tradeline.

Use the card at least once every few months to keep it active. Set a reminder to make a small purchase quarterly, then pay it off immediately.

Maxing Out the Card

Using your entire credit limit, even if you pay it off in full, can temporarily spike your credit utilization and lower your score. Credit utilization is calculated based on your statement balance, so high balances can hurt your score even if you never carry debt month-to-month.

Real-World Example: Store Card vs. Secured Card

Let me show you how these options compare in practice.

Scenario: Taylor has no credit history and wants to build credit to eventually qualify for travel rewards cards.

Option 1: Target Circle Store Card

• Approval: Likely approved with 15% off first purchase
• Credit limit: $500
• Interest rate: 27.99% APR
• Usability: Only at Target stores
• Monthly strategy: $50 purchase, paid in full
• After 12 months: 12 months of positive payment history, but limited credit profile

Option 2: Discover it Secured Card

• Approval: Likely approved with $200 deposit
• Credit limit: $200 (matches deposit)
• Interest rate: 28.24% APR (doesn't matter if paid in full)
• Usability: Anywhere Discover is accepted
• Monthly strategy: $50 purchase, paid in full, plus earn 2% cash back at gas stations and restaurants
• After 12 months: 12 months of positive payment history, $24+ in cash back earned, and Discover reviews account for upgrade to unsecured card with deposit returned

The secured card offers more flexibility, rewards, and a clear path to upgrading, making it the better choice for most credit builders despite requiring an upfront deposit.

The Bottom Line: Should You Get a Store Card?

Store credit cards can help you build credit, but they're rarely your best option. They work through the same credit-building mechanisms as regular cards but come with significant limitations that can actually make building credit harder if you're not careful.

If you've been denied for secured cards and student cards, a store card where you already shop regularly can serve as a starting point. Use it for small, planned purchases, pay the balance in full every month, and treat it as a temporary tool while you work toward qualifying for more flexible credit products.

However, for most people building credit, a secured credit card offers better value, more flexibility, and fewer risks. The upfront deposit might seem like a barrier, but it's a small price to pay for a tool that helps you build credit more effectively while earning rewards and establishing better spending habits.

Whatever you choose, remember that building credit is about consistent, responsible behavior over time. No single card will magically fix your credit score, but any card used wisely can be a valuable tool in your credit-building journey.

This article contains affiliate links. If you apply through our links, we may earn a commission at no cost to you, which helps us continue sharing points and miles strategies with the community.