Key Points

• The Capital One Venture X offers better value at $395 annually versus the Amex Platinum's $695 fee.
• Amex Platinum provides superior lounge access and elite status benefits across multiple programs.
• Venture X delivers more flexible redemption options with straightforward 1:1 transfer ratios.

Introduction

The premium travel card space has never been more competitive. For years, the Amex Platinum ruled as the undisputed king of luxury travel cards. Then Capital One launched the Venture X in 2021, and suddenly travelers had a serious alternative that costs $300 less annually while delivering comparable benefits.

I've spent the past three years using both cards extensively, and the question I get most often is simple: which one should you actually carry? The answer depends on your travel style, spending patterns, and which ecosystem benefits you'll genuinely use. Let me break down exactly how these two premium powerhouses compare so you can make the right choice for your wallet.

Quick Answer

The Capital One Venture X wins on value and simplicity with its $395 annual fee and straightforward rewards structure. The Amex Platinum justifies its $695 fee for frequent travelers who maximize lounge access, elite status benefits, and the extensive credit package. Most travelers will find better overall value with the Venture X, but luxury-focused travelers who value premium experiences may prefer the Platinum's prestige and perks.

Annual Fee and Credits Breakdown

Let's start with the most obvious difference: cost.

Capital One Venture X

• Annual Fee: $395
• Travel Credit: $300 annually (applies automatically to Capital One Travel purchases)
• Anniversary Bonus: 10,000 miles (worth $100)
• Effective Annual Fee: Free after credits ($395 - $300 - $100 = -$5)

The Venture X's credits are refreshingly simple. Book through Capital One Travel, get $300 back. Earn your anniversary bonus. Done. No tracking multiple small credits or remembering to use specific services.

Amex Platinum

• Annual Fee: $695
• Airline Fee Credit: $200 annually (limited to one airline)
• Uber Credit: $200 annually ($15/month + $20 in December)
• Saks Credit: $100 annually ($50 each half)
• Hotel Credit: $200 annually (Fine Hotels + Resorts and The Hotel Collection)
• Walmart+ Credit: $155 annually
• Digital Entertainment Credit: $240 annually ($20/month for streaming services)
• Equinox Credit: $300 annually
• Effective Annual Fee: Potentially free if you use everything

Here's the catch with the Platinum: you need to actively use eight different credits to offset the fee. Miss a few, and that $695 stings. I've found that most cardholders realistically use 3-4 of these credits regularly, making the effective fee around $300-400.

The Platinum Card from American Express requires discipline to maximize all those credits. The Venture X just gives you $300 back without the homework.

Earning Rewards

Capital One Venture X Earning Rates

• 10x miles per $1 on hotels and rental cars through Capital One Travel
• 5x miles per $1 on flights through Capital One Travel
• 2x miles per $1 on everything else

Capital One miles are worth 1 cent each when booking through their portal or transferred to partners. This means you're earning an effective 2% back on all purchases as a baseline, with 5-10% back on travel booked through their portal.

Amex Platinum Earning Rates

• 5x points per $1 on flights booked directly with airlines or through Amex Travel (up to $500,000 per year)
• 5x points per $1 on prepaid hotels through Amex Travel
• 1x point per $1 on everything else

The Platinum's earning structure is less generous for everyday spending. You're getting 1% back on most purchases, which is mediocre for a premium card. The 5x on flights is excellent, but only if you're booking directly with airlines or through Amex Travel.

Winner for earning: Venture X. The 2x everywhere baseline is significantly better than 1x, and the portal bonuses are competitive.

Welcome Bonuses

Both cards regularly offer substantial welcome bonuses, though offers vary.

Current Offers (December 2024)

• Venture X: 75,000 miles after $4,000 spend in 3 months (worth $750)
• Amex Platinum: 80,000 points after $8,000 spend in 6 months (worth $800-1,000+ depending on redemption)

The Capital One Venture X Rewards Credit Card typically requires less spending to earn the bonus, while Amex demands higher spend but offers potentially more valuable points.

Airport Lounge Access

This is where things get interesting.

Capital One Venture X Lounge Access

• Priority Pass Select: Unlimited visits with 2 guests
• Plaza Premium: Unlimited visits
• Capital One Lounges: Unlimited visits (currently in DFW, DEN, IAD with more planned)

The Venture X gives you solid lounge access that covers most travel scenarios. The Capital One Lounges themselves are legitimately excellent when available, and Priority Pass provides good global coverage.

Amex Platinum Lounge Access

• Centurion Lounges: Unlimited visits (best airport lounges globally)
• Priority Pass Select: Unlimited visits (no guests in restaurants)
• Delta Sky Clubs: When flying Delta
• Plaza Premium: Unlimited visits
• Escape Lounges: Unlimited visits
• International lounge networks: Including Lufthansa, Airspace, and others

The Platinum Card from American Express wins decisively on lounge access. Centurion Lounges are simply better than most Priority Pass locations, and the additional access to Delta Sky Clubs and international lounges provides more options.

If you fly through hubs with Centurion Lounges (like Phoenix, Seattle, New York, or Dallas) more than 10 times annually, the Platinum's lounge access alone could justify the higher fee.

Winner for lounges: Amex Platinum, especially for frequent flyers through Centurion-served airports.

Elite Status and Hotel Benefits

Capital One Venture X

• No automatic elite status with hotels or airlines
• No hotel benefits beyond booking through their portal

Amex Platinum

• Marriott Bonvoy Gold Elite: Automatic status (room upgrades, late checkout, bonus points)
• Hilton Honors Gold Elite: Automatic status (similar benefits)
• National Car Rental Executive Elite: Automatic status
• Hertz President's Circle: Automatic status
• Fine Hotels + Resorts: Additional benefits when booking qualifying properties
• The Hotel Collection: Benefits at 1,000+ hotels

The Platinum's elite status benefits are valuable for hotel loyalists. Marriott Bonvoy Gold Elite means potential room upgrades, late checkout, and bonus points on every stay. Hilton Gold provides similar perks.

If you stay 20+ hotel nights annually with Marriott or Hilton, these status benefits add real value. However, if you primarily use Hyatt or IHG, these benefits don't help.

Winner for status: Amex Platinum, but only if you use Marriott or Hilton.

Transfer Partners

Both cards offer transferable points, but the partner networks differ.

Capital One Transfer Partners

• Airlines: Air Canada, Air France/KLM, Avianca, British Airways, Cathay Pacific, Emirates, Etihad, EVA Air, Finnair, Qantas, Qatar Airways, Singapore Airlines, TAP Air Portugal, Turkish Airlines, Virgin Atlantic, Wyndham
• Hotels: Accor, Choice, Wyndham
• Transfer Ratio: 1:1 for all partners

Capital One's airline transfer partner list is excellent. Emirates, Qatar, and Singapore Airlines are premium options for luxury redemptions. The 1:1 ratio is straightforward.

Amex Membership Rewards Transfer Partners

• Airlines: Aeroplan, AeroMexico, Air France/KLM, Avianca, British Airways, Cathay Pacific, Delta, Emirates, Etihad, Hawaiian, Iberia, JetBlue, Qantas, Singapore Airlines, Virgin Atlantic
• Hotels: Marriott Bonvoy, Hilton Honors, Choice

Amex offers Delta transfers (Capital One doesn't), which is valuable for Delta loyalists. The hotel options include Marriott and Hilton, though transfers to hotels rarely offer good value.

Winner for transfers: Slight edge to Amex for Delta inclusion, but both networks are strong. If you fly Delta frequently, Amex wins. Otherwise, it's a tie.

Purchase Protections and Benefits

Both Cards Offer

• Extended warranty protection
• Purchase protection
• Travel accident insurance
• Baggage delay insurance
• Trip cancellation/interruption insurance
• Car rental coverage
• No foreign transaction fees

Amex Platinum Adds

• Global Assist Hotline
• Amex Fine Hotels + Resorts benefits
• Amex Global Lounge Collection access
• Return protection (up to $300 per item)

The protections are comparable, though Amex provides slightly more comprehensive coverage. For most travelers, the differences won't matter daily.

Portal Booking Experience

Capital One Travel Portal

The Capital One Travel portal is powered by Hopper and offers competitive pricing. The 10x on hotels and 5x on flights makes booking through the portal attractive, and prices are generally fair compared to booking direct.

I've found the search functionality good, though not always as comprehensive as Amex Travel. The Capital One Venture X makes portal booking worthwhile with the boosted earning rates.

Amex Travel Portal

Amex Travel provides access to Fine Hotels + Resorts (FHR) and The Hotel Collection, which offer additional benefits like breakfast, property credits, and upgrades at luxury hotels. If you're booking high-end properties, these perks add value.

For straightforward flight and hotel bookings, the portals are comparable. For luxury hotel stays, Amex offers more.

Who Should Choose the Capital One Venture X?

The Capital One Venture X Rewards Credit Card makes sense if you:

1. Want simpler value: The $300 credit and 10,000 anniversary miles are straightforward
2. Prefer flexible redemptions: 2x everywhere means solid returns without category tracking
3. Don't need extensive credits: You won't use 8 different credits from the Platinum
4. Value cost efficiency: The effective fee is essentially zero after credits
5. Fly through multiple airports: Priority Pass provides broader (if less premium) coverage

Best Venture X Strategy

Charge everything to the card for 2x everywhere, book travel through the Capital One portal for boosted rates, transfer to partners for premium cabin international flights. Your $300 credit applies automatically, and the 10,000 anniversary miles arrive without effort.

Who Should Choose the Amex Platinum?

The Platinum Card from American Express makes sense if you:

1. Maximize multiple credits: You'll actually use Uber, Saks, streaming, and other specific credits
2. Frequent Centurion hubs: You regularly access airports with Centurion Lounges
3. Stay at Marriott/Hilton: The automatic Gold status provides value
4. Book luxury hotels: Fine Hotels + Resorts benefits are worth it for premium properties
5. Fly Delta extensively: Delta transfer partners and Sky Club access matter
6. Value prestige: The metal card and brand recognition appeal to you

Best Amex Platinum Strategy

Use the credits methodically (set monthly reminders), leverage Centurion Lounges, transfer points to partners for outsized value, book luxury hotels through FHR for added perks. Track your credits to ensure you're offsetting that $695 fee.

The Math: Which Offers Better Value?

Let's calculate value for a typical frequent traveler:

Venture X Annual Value

• Annual fee: -$395
• Travel credit: +$300 (easy to use)
• Anniversary bonus: +$100
• Lounge access: +$300 (estimated 10 visits)
• Net value: +$305

Amex Platinum Annual Value

• Annual fee: -$695
• Credits realistically used: +$500 (travel, Uber, streaming)
• Lounge access: +$500 (estimated 15 Centurion visits)
• Hotel status: +$200 (estimated upgrade value)
• Net value: +$505

On paper, the Platinum offers more value. In practice, you need to actively use those credits and benefits. Miss several credits or don't use lounges often, and the Venture X provides better real-world value.

For most travelers, the Capital One Venture X delivers better practical value. For luxury-focused travelers who maximize every benefit, the Amex Platinum can justify the premium.

Can You Carry Both?

Absolutely. Many serious travelers carry both cards because they complement each other well:

• Use Venture X for everyday 2x spending and portal bookings
• Use Amex Platinum for direct airline bookings (5x), Centurion Lounge access, and luxury hotel bookings
• Combine points through strategic transfers to maximize redemption value

If you spend enough on travel to justify two premium cards, this combo provides maximum flexibility and benefits coverage.

Comparison to Chase Sapphire Reserve

While we're comparing premium cards, it's worth noting how these stack up against the Chase Sapphire Reserve. The CSR sits between these two at $550 annually, offering 3x on travel/dining and Priority Pass access, plus Chase's excellent transfer partners.

For more details, check out why the Capital One Venture X might be better than the Chase Sapphire Reserve.

Making Your Decision

Here's my honest take after using both extensively:

Choose the Capital One Venture X if you want maximum value with minimum effort. The card essentially pays for itself, earns well everywhere, and provides solid travel benefits without requiring you to track eight different credits.

Choose the Amex Platinum if you're willing to actively manage credits and benefits in exchange for access to the best airport lounges, automatic hotel elite status, and the prestige of carrying one of the world's most recognized premium cards.

Choose both if you travel frequently enough to justify two annual fees and want access to all available benefits across both ecosystems.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which card has better customer service?

Both offer excellent customer service. Amex is legendary for taking care of cardholders, while Capital One has significantly improved their premium card support. You'll be well-served by either.

Can I product change to either card?

Capital One allows product changes from Venture cards to Venture X if you qualify. Amex doesn't allow product changes to the Platinum—you must apply directly.

Which transfer partners offer the best value?

For both cards, Singapore Airlines (for premium cabin), Air France/KLM (for Flying Blue sweet spots), and British Airways (for short-haul flights) consistently offer excellent value. The Chase Ultimate Rewards Complete Guide explains transfer strategies in more detail.

Do these cards count toward Chase 5/24?

Yes, both cards count as new accounts for Chase's 5/24 rule. If you're under 5/24 and considering Chase cards, review what is Chase's 5/24 rule before applying.

Can I use the Venture X travel credit on any travel purchase?

The $300 credit applies only to purchases made through Capital One Travel. It won't credit automatically for direct bookings with airlines or hotels.

Are the Amex Platinum credits worth tracking?

If you'll naturally use at least 5-6 of the credits (travel, Uber, streaming, and a few others), yes. If tracking feels like homework you'll ignore, the Venture X's simplicity wins.

Conclusion

The Capital One Venture X versus Amex Platinum debate doesn't have a universal answer. The Venture X delivers outstanding value with minimal effort, making it perfect for travelers who want premium benefits without complexity. The Amex Platinum offers more extensive perks and prestige but requires active credit management to justify the higher fee.

For most readers, I recommend starting with the Capital One Venture X Rewards Credit Card. The effectively zero annual fee after credits makes it a no-brainer, the 2x everywhere earning is excellent, and the benefits are genuinely useful without demanding constant attention.

If you fly through Centurion hub airports weekly, stay at Marriott/Hilton properties monthly, and will actively use multiple credits, upgrade to the Platinum Card from American Express. The prestige and benefits can justify the premium for the right traveler.

Both cards are excellent. The question is which one fits your travel style and how much effort you want to invest in maximizing benefits. Choose based on your actual behavior, not aspirational travel plans.

This article contains affiliate links. If you apply through our links, we may earn a commission at no cost to you, which helps us continue sharing points and miles strategies with the community.