Key Points
- The Amex Gold earns 4x points at restaurants with $250 in annual dining credits that offset the $325 fee.
- Capital One SavorOne offers 3% cash back on dining with no annual fee for straightforward value.
- Chase Sapphire Preferred's 3x on dining becomes 4.5 cents per dollar when you transfer points to partners.
Introduction
If you're spending $500+ monthly on restaurants, you're leaving serious money on the table without the right dining credit card. Here's the thing: not all "dining rewards" are created equal. A card earning 4x points sounds great until you realize those points are only worth 1 cent each, while another card's 2x points might be worth 2 cents each when transferred to airline partners.
I'm going to walk you through the cards that actually deliver value for restaurant spending, with real numbers showing exactly what your rewards are worth. No flowery language about "culinary adventures"—just the math on which cards earn you the most back on your dining budget.
How We Evaluated These Cards
Here's what matters for dining rewards:
- Earning rate: Points or cash back per dollar
- Point value: What those rewards are actually worth
- Annual fee: Does it make sense for your spending?
- Additional perks: Credits, benefits that offset the cost
I've calculated the actual return for each card based on realistic dining spend levels, so you can see exactly what you'd earn.
Best Overall: American Express Gold Card
The Numbers:
- Annual fee: $325
- Dining earning: 4x Membership Rewards points
- Dining credits: $120 Uber Cash + $120 dining credit from select partners
- Point value: 2 cents each when transferred (conservative estimate)
- Real return: 8% on dining when you use transfer partners
Why it wins:The Amex Gold is the standard-bearer for dining rewards, and the math backs it up. If you spend $1,000 monthly on dining (very achievable for a household), you're earning 48,000 points per year—worth $960 when transferred to airline partners.
Add the $240 in dining-related credits, and you're getting $1,200 in value against a $325 fee. That's a $875 net gain before considering the welcome bonus.
Best for: People who can use the dining credits and are willing to transfer points to airline partners for maximum value.
Not ideal for: If you want simple cash back or won't use Uber Cash and partner dining credits, the fee won't make sense.
Apply for the American Express Gold Card
Best No Annual Fee: Capital One SavorOne
The Numbers:
- Annual fee: $0
- Dining earning: 3% cash back
- Additional categories: 3% on entertainment, streaming, groceries
- Real return: 3% straight cash back
Why it's great:Sometimes the best strategy is the simplest one. Three percent cash back on dining with zero annual fee means every dollar you spend at restaurants earns you 3 cents back. No calculations, no transfer partners, no credits to track.
If you spend $500 monthly on dining, that's $180 back per year. Zero strings attached.
Best for: People who want straightforward rewards without annual fees or people building a card collection who need a no-fee dining option.
The catch: You'll earn less than premium cards, but you also pay nothing for the privilege.
Best for Transferable Points: Chase Sapphire Preferred
The Numbers:
- Annual fee: $95
- Dining earning: 3x Ultimate Rewards points
- Point value: 1.25 cents through Chase portal, 1.5-2 cents via transfers
- Real return: 4.5-6% when transferring to partners
Why it's worth considering:The Chase Sapphire Preferred hits a sweet spot: reasonable annual fee, strong earning rate, and access to valuable transfer partners like Hyatt, United, and Southwest.
Here's the real value: those 3x points are worth 1.5 cents each (minimum) when you transfer them to travel partners. That means you're getting 4.5% back on dining—better return than most cash back cards.
On $8,000 annual dining spend, you'd earn 24,000 points worth $360 when transferred. Subtract the $95 fee, and you're up $265.
Best for: People who want flexible points that work for both hotels and flights, without the steep fees of premium cards.
Consider this: The card also earns 5x on Chase Travel portal bookings and 2x on all other travel.
Apply for Chase Sapphire Preferred
Best Premium Option: Chase Sapphire Reserve
The Numbers:
- Annual fee: $550
- Dining earning: 3x Ultimate Rewards points
- Travel credit: $300 annual
- Point value: 1.5 cents through portal, 1.5-2 cents via transfers
- Real return: 4.5-6% on dining, $300 reduces effective fee to $250
When it makes sense:The Reserve only beats the Preferred if you're using the $300 travel credit and other premium benefits like Priority Pass lounge access. But if you travel frequently and spend heavily on dining, the math works.
At $1,500 monthly dining spend ($18,000/year), you'd earn 54,000 points worth $810 when transferred. Add the $300 travel credit, and you're getting $1,110 in value against a $550 fee.
Best for: Frequent travelers who'll use lounge access, travel insurance, and premium benefits beyond just dining rewards.
Skip it if: You're purely optimizing for dining rewards. The Preferred or Amex Gold deliver better pure dining value.
Get the Chase Sapphire Reserve
Best for High Spenders: Citi Strata Premier
The Numbers:
- Annual fee: $95
- Dining earning: 3x ThankYou Points
- Point value: 1-1.25 cents for travel redemptions
- Real return: 3-3.75% on dining
Why it's competitive:The Strata Premier earns 3x on dining, gas stations, groceries, and air travel—making it a strong everyday card if you spend across all these categories.
ThankYou Points aren't as valuable as Chase or Amex points for transfers, but the card's low annual fee makes it accessible. If you're spending $1,000 monthly on combined dining and groceries, you're earning 36,000 points annually worth $360-450 in travel.
Best for: People who want one card covering multiple bonus categories without a premium annual fee.
The limitation: Fewer valuable transfer partners compared to Chase or Amex.
Best Flat-Rate Cash Back: Wells Fargo Autograph
The Numbers:
- Annual fee: $0
- Dining earning: 3x points on dining, travel, gas, transit, streaming, phone
- Point value: 1 cent each for cash back or travel
- Real return: 3% across multiple categories
What sets it apart:Three percent back on dining, travel, gas stations, streaming, and phone plans with no annual fee. If you spend across all these categories, the value adds up quickly without the complexity of transfer partners.
The beauty is flexibility: redeem for cash back or use points for travel at 1 cent each. Simple, predictable, free.
Best for: People who want better-than-average cash back across lifestyle spending without annual fees or point transfers.
Consider: Less valuable than transferable point cards if you're willing to optimize redemptions.
Cards That Didn't Make the Cut
Capital One Savor ($95 annual fee): Earns 4% on dining and entertainment, but the SavorOne gives you 3% for free. Unless you're spending $9,500+ on these categories annually, the math doesn't work.
Discover it (rotating 5%): Great when restaurants are the quarterly category, but you can't rely on it year-round for dining rewards.
Bank of America Custom Cash: Three percent on dining is solid, but only if you choose dining as your category—and you might get better value choosing a different category.
How to Choose Your Dining Card
If you spend under $300/month on dining:Stick with a no-fee card like Capital One SavorOne or Wells Fargo Autograph. The 3% return is excellent, and you're not paying for premium benefits you won't use.
If you spend $300-800/month on dining:The Amex Gold or Chase Sapphire Preferred make sense. The Amex Gold wins if you can use the dining credits; the Sapphire Preferred wins if you want flexibility and lower fees.
If you spend $800+/month on dining:Premium cards become no-brainers. The Amex Gold's 4x points and dining credits deliver serious value at this spend level.
If you want the absolute simplest option:Capital One SavorOne or Wells Fargo Autograph. Three percent back, no fees, no complexity.
The Real Math on Dining Rewards
Let me show you what these cards actually earn on realistic spending:
$500 monthly dining spend ($6,000/year):
- Amex Gold: 24,000 points = $480 value + $240 credits = $720 - $325 fee = $395 net
- Capital One SavorOne: $180 cash back - $0 fee = $180 net
- Chase Sapphire Preferred: 18,000 points = $270 value - $95 fee = $175 net
$1,000 monthly dining spend ($12,000/year):
- Amex Gold: 48,000 points = $960 value + $240 credits = $1,200 - $325 = $875 net
- Chase Sapphire Preferred: 36,000 points = $540 value - $95 = $445 net
- Capital One SavorOne: $360 cash back - $0 = $360 net
The break-even points are clear: Amex Gold dominates at $500+ monthly spend if you use the credits. Below that, no-fee cards make more sense.
Stacking Strategies
Here's something most people miss: you don't need just one dining card.
The optimizer's approach:
- Amex Gold for most dining (4x points)
- Capital One SavorOne for backup when Amex isn't accepted
- Chase Sapphire Preferred for dining at small merchants (Amex acceptance issues)
The simple approach:Pick one card, use it everywhere. The mental overhead of optimizing every purchase isn't worth an extra 1% for most people.
Common Questions
Can I use multiple dining cards?
Yes, but manage it strategically. I use Amex Gold as my primary dining card and keep a Visa/Mastercard as backup for places that don't take Amex.
Are the dining credits actually useful?
The Amex Gold's Uber Cash works at Uber Eats, making it easy to use. The dining credits require more planning—you need to use partner restaurants or services. If you order delivery regularly, you'll use them. If not, factor that into your calculation.
Should I transfer points or use the travel portal?
Almost always transfer for maximum value. Chase points are worth 1.25-1.5 cents through their portal but 1.5-2+ cents when transferred to partners like Hyatt. Amex points are worth 1 cent through their portal but 2+ cents transferred to airlines.
What if I rarely dine out?
Then none of these cards make sense as your primary card. Focus on cards that match your actual spending. A flat 2% cash back card beats specialized dining rewards if you're only spending $100 monthly at restaurants.
Bottom Line
The best dining credit card depends entirely on your spending level and whether you're willing to optimize point transfers:
- Spending under $300/month: Capital One SavorOne or Wells Fargo Autograph
- Spending $300-800/month: Amex Gold (if using credits) or Chase Sapphire Preferred
- Spending $800+/month: Amex Gold, no question
- Want simplicity over optimization: Capital One SavorOne
Don't overthink this. Pick a card that matches your spending, use it consistently, and you'll rack up meaningful rewards. The difference between the "perfect" choice and the "good enough" choice is usually less than $100 annually—not worth the mental energy for most people.
This article contains affiliate links. If you apply through our links, we may earn a commission at no cost to you, which helps us continue sharing points and miles strategies with the community.
